深度评测DeepSeek、ChatGPT O1和谷歌Gemini AI应用开发场景

深度评测DeepSeek、ChatGPT O1和谷歌Gemini AI应用开发场景 - DeepSeek性能完胜！

下面我会展示我为期一周的实验结果，创作不宜，希望大家关注我，以后多多互3！前一阵我在互联网上看到很多关于DeepSeek R1的讨论，这个开源模型据说可以媲美，甚至优于像OpenAI o1这样的付费模型。

由于我在日常工作中广泛使用这些AI模型（主要在Cursor里使用这些AI），我决定看看哪个最适合代码开发。经过200次的Cursor实验后，我在这里和大家分享这次实验的结果。

实验配置

我从一个AI代码开排行榜 - lmarena中选择了前两名的模型，即Gemini-Exp-1206和OpenAI的o1，以及挑战者——DeepSeek R1作为对比。然后我设计了三个实用的编程场景来测试每个模型的能力：

1. 情绪追踪Web应用

主要功能包括：在日历上进行情绪记录、视觉化追踪情绪、图表数据可视化

2. 随机食谱生成器

主要功能包括集成MealDB API、食谱类别筛选、收藏夹管理

3. “打地鼠”游戏

主要内容有实时动画、添加音效、游戏的难度会递增

我是如何测试每个模型的？

我对所有三个AI开发场景都使用了相同的测试流程：

1. 编写简要需求文档

我列出了每个项目的核心功能，比如“使用日历API库”、“用本地存储保存数据”或“从外部API获取数据”等。

2. 让AI生成完整代码

我将需求文档提供给模型并等待代码生成结束。如果代码有Bug或缺少功能，我会提供具体的反馈（比如“情绪的颜色编码显示错误”），直到模型修正问题并达到可用状态。

3. 评分结果

当应用运行后，我按照提前制定好的评分表进行测试：比如主要功能是否正常？代码是否结构清晰？用户体验是否良好？最终我为每个模型给出了评分。

4. 结果对比

在完成所有三个应用的测试后，我整理了最终数据并统计得分。

代码生成流程

以下是一个我是用的示例PRD（产品需求文档）：

---
name: "Mood Tracker"
about: "Modern mood tracking web app with data visualization"
date_created: "2025-01-26"
project_name: "MoodTracker"
tech_stack: ["NextJS 15", "TypeScript", "Shadcn", "Tailwind CSS", "Chart.js", "date-fns"]
version: "1.3"
---# 🎯 Mood Tracker PRDA modern web application for logging daily moods and visualizing emotional trends with charts.---## 1. **Success Criteria**1. **Core Functionality**- [ ] **Clickable Calendar**: Users can select a date to log or edit a mood entry.- [ ] **Emoji & Note Input**: A modal or dialog with an emoji picker and text field.- [ ] **Local Data Storage**: Persist mood entries between sessions.- [ ] **Data Visualization**: At least two Chart.js charts to display weekly, monthly, or overall trends.- [ ] **Mobile-Responsive**: Layout should adjust for smaller screens without major issues.2. **Validation Checklist**- [ ] **Build & Run**: Fresh `npm install && npm run dev` works without errors.- [ ] **Calendar Interaction**: Clicking a calendar date opens the mood logging UI.- [ ] **Color Coding**: Each date cell or icon changes based on mood score or emoji.- [ ] **Chart Page**: A separate page or section to visualize stats (e.g., line chart + pie chart).- [ ] **Data Persistence**: Entries remain available if the user navigates away and comes back later.---## 2. **Tech Stack**- **NextJS 15** (App Router) for site structure
- **TypeScript** for type safety
- **Shadcn** UI components (dialogs, buttons, forms)
- **Tailwind CSS** for styling
- **Chart.js** for data visualization
- **date-fns** for date operations
- **localforage** (or equivalent) for local data storage
- **@emoji-mart/react** for an emoji picker### **Why These Choices?**
- **NextJS + TypeScript**: Great for server/client flexibility and type safety
- **Shadcn + Tailwind**: Rapid UI development with consistent design
- **Chart.js**: Straightforward library for rendering charts
- **date-fns**: Lightweight date utilities---## 3. **Design & Mood Scores**| MoodScore | Mood       | Tailwind Color | Emoji     |
|-----------|------------|----------------|-----------|
| 1         | Angry      | `red-500`      | 😡         |
| 2         | Sad        | `orange-400`   | 😞         |
| 3         | Neutral    | `yellow-300`   | 😐         |
| 4         | Happy      | `lime-400`     | 😊         |
| 5         | Ecstatic   | `emerald-500`  | 😄         |> You can style each date cell background or display an icon to indicate the logged mood.---## 4. **User Stories**1. **Daily Mood Logging**- **As a user**, I want to quickly log how I feel each day so I can track my emotional journey.- **Given** I click on a specific date- **When** I choose an emoji and type a note- **Then** the date on the calendar updates visually to reflect my mood2. **Mood Analysis**- **As a user**, I want to see a higher-level overview of my moods so I can spot trends.- **Given** I navigate to a “Stats” page- **When** I select a timeframe (weekly, monthly, etc.)- **Then** I see at least two types of charts illustrating changes or distributions in my mood data---## 5. **Data Structures**```typescript
export interface MoodEntry {date: string;    // e.g. "2025-01-23"emoji: string;   // e.g. "😊"note: string;moodScore: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5;
}
```- Store mood entries in `lib/storage.ts` using local data storage (e.g., localforage).
- Components like `MoodCalendar` and `MoodChart` can import these entries to display logs.### 6. File Structure
```mood-tracker/
├── app/
│   ├── (dashboard)/
│   │   └── page.tsx     # main calendar view
│   ├── stats/
│   │   └── page.tsx     # charts & statistics
│   └── layout.tsx       # global layout or shared UI
├── components/
│   ├── MoodCalendar.tsx
│   ├── MoodChart.tsx
│   └── EmojiPicker.tsx
├── lib/
│   ├── storage.ts
│   └── mood.ts          # data types
└── styles/└── globals.css
```### 7. Additional Notes
- **Shadcn**: Ideal for modals (Dialog component), buttons, forms, etc.
- **Chart.js**: Use a line chart, bar chart, pie chart, or any combination to showcase data trends.
- **Optional**: You can add a hover tooltip on each calendar day to preview the note or emoji.